It’s the spring semester, and along with that label come fraternity and sorority rushing and pledging. You’ll be hard pressed to find a day in which you don’t hear girls raving about their “bigs,” “sisters,” “families,” and the like. If you pay close enough attention, you may also hear guys complaining about the time-consuming and stressful nature of pledging. These facets, though apparently frivolous, aren’t really offensive. Rather, Greek Life, through heteronormativity and the reinforcement of the gender binary, is offensive to the LGBT community.
The core notion of Greek life is a collection of individuals with similar interests who get together for social interaction. These social interactions include parties and “mixers”. Parties, typically hosted by fraternities, very often uphold the qualities of heteronormativity because of their exclusivity based on gender. For example, fraternities will host parties that only female community members can attend. This is under several assumptions about males and females that pin the LGBT community as belonging to another, or abnormal, demographic.
Primarily, this assumes that all male members of the fraternity are heterosexual. Let’s face it; we know that frat parties are centered on hook up culture. Thus, if only female community members are allowed to attend frat parties, then we can logically assume that all members in the frat are heterosexual. This is clearly not the case. Quite a few gay and bisexual men are out to their fraternities, but one of these students has told me that in order for men outside of the fraternity to attend the party, they will need to be on a list. Therefore, fraternities will marginalize its gay and bisexual members by requiring them to list men with whom they would like to hook up with.
Additionally, this tenet of Greek Life assumes that all male community members seeking entrance to a frat party are heterosexual, trying to “steal” the women. I have encountered this in my own experience, and protesting, claiming my homosexuality proves futile (perhaps because of an aversion to homosexuals and inherent homophobia in the Greek system).
I’ve discussed this with members of fraternities. They offer an alternative rationalization that males are denied entry to frat parties because they pose a safety hazard and are more likely to cause damage. This offensively pins a flaw to my entire gender, clearly a very large demographic.
Fraternities and sororities engage in “mixers,” events at which hooking up is central to the experience, according to my friends in Greek life. Once again heteronormativity comes into play, as it is the assumption that all members in fraternities in sororities will want to hook up with a member of the opposite sex. Clearly it would be equivalent to incest, should “brothers” and “sisters” hook up with members of the same group, so hooking up for gay and lesbian members is non-existent. Again, these qualities are highly marginalizing to the gay, lesbian, and bisexual communities.
Offense to transgender students is easy to point out. Fraternities are for men. Sororities are for women. At an institution like Duke, we should be asking ourselves the questions such as “In what kind of Greek group do transgender students belong?” and “What are out gender-neutral Greek options?” Though I don’t know the answers to my own questions, I would like somebody to indulge my curiosity.
As outlined, Greek Life, though it includes members from a broad range of backgrounds in regards to sexual orientation, only superficially appeals to cisgender heterosexuals. As a result, I think it’s time that our institution take action. Let’s extend gender neutrality beyond the realms of just independent residence halls and certain selective living groups. Let’s begin to take action in conjunction the Interfraternity Council and the Panhellenic Association to make the entire Greek scene less offensive to a large portion of the LGBT community. I invite you to discuss whether these changes are appropriate, and how we can effectively make such adjustments.
-Daniel Kort
March 6, 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

4 comments:
As a private institution, they are entitled to make whatever choices they wish. If their goal is to put their penis in as many vaginas as they can, then maybe keeping other guys away is the logical choice of action.
For me, personally, I see this as a blessing; one less chance to get caught up in the shallow, empty hook up community.
I had to split this into two comments because it was too long. Sorry :P
Hey Daniel,
So, I see your points here and I totally understand where you are coming from., but I think you are off-base in a lot of these generalizations of the greek community.
1) You say that the core notion of Greek life is just to facilitate social interaction. I think that is a very superficial view to take on Greek life. What you may see on the outside is just the social aspects of Greek life i.e. parties and mixers. What you don't see or know are the other activities that happen out of the public eye that create and foster brother/sisterhood and emphasize the ideals on which the organization is founded. This eternal bond that connects you to not only the people in your chapter here at Duke but also worldwide is the true notion of Greek life. It's the notion that you are joining an organization and becoming a part of something that is bigger than yourself. At least, that's why I and many other people I know joined a Greek organization.
2) These parties that you refer to that are only open to females or guys have to be on a list to get in only occur in certain circumstances. If a fraternity is having a mixer with a sorority, then, it makes sense for only females to be invited. That's the point of mixers. If a fraternity is having an invite-only party, then EVERYONE has to be on list or have a brother that can vouch for them.
3) While hooking up does happen a lot at fraternity parties, I don't think it's fair to say that that's the only thing they're good for. I know several people who go just because they are actually friends with people in the fraternity and use it as a chance to hang out on the weekend. As to your point about all members being heterosexual due to only females being invited, I think you're forgetting that gay and bisexual males can have female friends that they want to invite to a party, too. I also think that you should be careful to not use one story to generalize to the entire community. Every fraternity has their own process for throwing parties and events. One experience does not equal them all (as clearly my experience does not equal the person's experience that you spoke with).
4) Once again, I think you are looking to much into this whole hook up thing. Yes, hook ups do happen at mixers but the real reason for them is to create ties and connections with the sorority. It's actually to "mix" so that a relationship is formed between the organizations. These relationships manifest themselves when the organizations have philanthropy events. The two organizations help each other raise money for their respective charities. And when more money is raised for charity, I consider that a good thing.
5) I've seen guys at parties be really destructive and cause damage that my fraternity has had to deal with after the party. It's happened several times. For any organization that has hosted a party, I'm sure they will tell you that that is a legitimate reason to be wary of some guys coming to your party.
Part 2:
6) I offer this (http://abcnews.go.com/Health/college-fraternity-helps-transgender-brother-pay-sex-change/story?id=18611183) in regards to your points about transgender members of a fraternity. Yes, this is only one fraternity and one instance of this but I think it shows that all fraternities are not as rigid and conservative as you might be lead to believe.
7) Yes, there are cases of homophobia and lots of heteronormativity in Greek organizations, especially fraternities, but in the same way that it’s not fair to stereotype all people of one race or gender in a certain way, it’s not fair to stereotype all Greek organizations. There are a wide variety of Greek organizations, even here at Duke. I think that you if actually took a look at all of them, you would see some where the behaviors you outlined do occur and some where that’s not the case at all. Those differences would even manifest (probably in different ways) in Greek organizations at other schools.
8) You say that Greek life only superficially appeals to cisgender heterosexuals. I agree with that, but if we as people are always going to judge a book by it’s cover, then where does that get us? I learned more about the organization and the brothers that comprise it before I decided that it was something I wanted to be connected to for the rest of my life. When I look at my brothers do I see a bunch of heterosexuals looking to get laid every weekend? In a few, yes, but overall, I see a group of guys that I am proud to be eternally bound to. I see guys that accept me as I am and encourage me to bring around any guy that I’m seeing so that they can “approve” him for me. I see guys that have opened up their idea of what a fraternity guy is and allowed me to become one of those “frat guys.” There is so much more that goes in behind the walls of Greek organizations that people don’t take the time and effort to learn about, choosing instead to keep a running tally of all the scandalous headlines they read. Give us a chance. We’re not all bad.
-AJ
Your prejudice against fraternities is unjustified. There is nothing inherently homophobic about fraternities. The percentage of fraternity members who are gay is approximately the same as that of independents. Here at Duke, the vast majority of fraternity parties are open. Mixers are usually with sororities, but brothers are allowed to bring dates separate from the members of the mixers. Those dates may be male or female. I speak as a gay member of a mostly heterosexual fraternity at Duke.
Post a Comment